Toby joyfully beats Spencer at Scrabble, and since Spencer's staying overnight was not planned, Toby gives her his shirt to sleep in, keeping the trousers for himself. Spencer gets a cut on her hand from the fire and she is at the hospital. Spencer's field hockey coach is her sister's ex-boyfriend, Ian, whom both Ali and Spencer had a crush on. Alex states that after Charlotte died she needed closure, and wanted it on her terms. Spencer realizes she has been set up. But keeping their mouths shut actually backfired! Emily asks what the daughter is like, and he responds eerily that she gets whatever she wants.
Spencer pulls down the flier, hoping she can share information with Toby and learn who is framing them both. However, they discover that Colin is actually a 33-year-old married man with a child, and team up to get back at him by spiking his soda water with before a tennis match. This at the time , fueled the Liars beliefs that Toby killed Ali. Alex was also set on becoming Spencer - she was jealous of the life that her twin sister was able to have, while she was bought by a rich British family but then abandoned. They kiss even more but Toby catching on that he was only wearing a towel, says she'll remember after he puts some clothes on. Spencer laughs a little and says that she missed him while Caleb and him were playing 'Hardy boys', but now isn't the time for that. She seems to relax after a while and then when Toby kisses her back, she turns around and they begin to make out on her couch.
Ella warns Hanna that Jamie may have traded the bell from the church for a new one of much lesser value. Emily spots Toby unloading a moving van on her way home. Mona visits Spencer at Radley and offers her the chance to join the A-Team, which Spencer, who wants answers on Toby, accepts. Toby is at Spencer's house, reading a book while she is doing her homework. Because he was drawn into the game like Sydney. Before he can say anything, she runs away.
They hug each other as Spencer tells him she needs a ride to her car. Garrett tells Spencer someone has them all fooled, that medical records don't lie. She starts laughing gleefully when Mary Drake walks up behind her and enters Spencer's room, where she states that they didn't think she'd wake up so soon. This scene also put into context why Spencer would never dream of leaking Yvonne's personal medical information. While Spencer and Toby are making out in Toby's truck Toby believes he spots something in Jason DiLaurentis's upstairs window but tells Spencer to ignore it. Hanna and Toby arrive at the church party while Spencer and Jason arrive at the antique shop.
Alex was given her birth name - Alex Drake. Spencer finds out that Charlotte was killed in a copycat manner off a murder she wrote an essay about in college, leading her to start thinking that the police could blame her for Charlotte's death. Ripped from her old life, she's thrown into the dysfunctional Hastings family. Later in the episode, Spencer and Toby are in her kitchen and Spencer is reading out Wilden's murder report in the newspaper while Toby makes her breakfast. Spencer leaves the hospital and Emily goes in the room with Toby. In a garment bag, they find what looks like a feather that matches the feather the girls got from the Black Swan dress. When he walks toward her, she slaps him for everything he did to her and her friends.
As the cop takes her by Mona, she looks at her and says that no one can call her Loser Mona anymore, and Mona responds that she doesn't know the half of it. She states that she never felt so close to someone so fast, and he felt the same way. It would also be a kind of reconciliation for Ali after all she did to him. And after, Spencer puts Toby's shirt on. It turns out that CeCe and Alison were friends and she used to date Jason. She says that Syndey was stealing from the back and Alex found out about it, and Sydney fit the hoodie. The rest of the girls arrive having been to the forest.
She then leaves, and Toby looks after her confused, as this contradicted what the real Spencer had said to him earlier. It turns out to be Toby who is taking a break from work because he wanted to give her flowers for their anniversary. They flip through the yearbook index of clubs to check for a description of the club, but there is none, leading them to believe that it was some sort of prank. Aria asks what happened to Toby's truck and Spencer says she drove it back to his house but she sat in it for a while and listened to the radio, possibly to remember all their good times and make-out sessions they had, but she begins to cry because she misses him. Spencer asks who she is, and Alex is surprised that her twin hasn't figured it out yet, and even questions how hard Mona hit her. Emily and Nate go to the old boat House, Maya's favorite spot in Rosewood. Luckily, it was only the Fat Controller, who had gotten into trouble in the snow.
Toby goes back to where her pillows are and Spencer asks him about Jenna. Emily is surprised when Shana invites her to coffee, only to introduce her to Olympic gold medalist. Easier than someone without a background like that. Emily assures her that she has always done everything she could to protect him. Toby begins to give her a back massage and Spencer begins to calm down. He has to see Spencer.
Spencer confronts Melissa and she reveals that she was the Black Swan and that she lost the baby the day after she found Ian's body. After Toby goes to get a room, Spencer hears flute music coming from Room 214 - the braille numbers! When she stood next to the fireplace, it erupted and gave her second-degree burns. However, she later discovers that the guy she thought was Chase was actually his brother, Curtis. Rosewood has its own set of rules. He can have his tracking anklet removed as soon as he goes to the Rosewood Police Department. At the hospital, Toby sees Wren.